Why is Health Insurance So Expensive?

Cathy Jakicic
August 15th, 2019 June 4th, 2019 |
Read time: 10 minutes
Health insurance ID card and money

Products mentioned in this blog post:

Find out if you qualify for temporary coverage for emergencies and hospitalization – Don’t go uninsured between major medical plans.

We’ve discussed how much health insurance costs and the factors that impact your individual or family premium, but why is health insurance so expensive?

Naturally, there are a number of factors, including:

  • Health insurance provider costs
  • Costs of claims, including healthcare and treatment costs
  • Rise of chronic illness and obesity
  • Recent changes to the Affordable Care Act (“ACA”)
  • Lack of competition with fewer carriers and plan options
  • Skyrocketing costs of prescription drugs

Many of these factors are out of your control, so smart decisions about your health insurance are especially important.

Let’s look at each of these factors in more detail and what you can do to impact your bottom line.

Insurance With Lower Monthly Premiums

Short term health insurance can provide temporary and limited benefits for a lower premium if you qualify. STM is not a replacement for comprehensive major medical coverage. 

Health Insurance Provider Operating Costs

When you pay your monthly premium, you’re paying for costs related directly to the services and medication you receive – think prescription drugs and doctor services – but also the insurance company’s general operating costs like fraud and abuse monitoring, customer engagement, regulatory licensing and fees, employee training and education, technology, and administration.

Don’t worry, the majority of your premium payment, or around 80%, goes to paying for healthcare claims.1

But operating costs are still a factor. These costs have gone down since the ACA took effect for two primary reasons:

  • A reduction in underwriting costs since major medical plans no longer determine rates based on health and medical history.2
  • Caps imposed by the ACA: 20% for group market insurers and 15% for the individual insurance providers.3

The caps are meant to incentivize insurers to find efficiency. If insurers exceed the cap, they pay a rebate to their policyholders.4

In 2016, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) reported administrative costs to break down across the different insurer markets as follows:5

  • Individual Health Insurance: 20%
  • Small Group: 16%
  • Large Group: 11%

By comparison, government-administered Medicare spent just 6.4% of total operating costs on administration for both their traditional insurance plans for seniors and workers with severe disabilities and their private plans in 2015.6

As you can see, there’s likely still room for administrative efficiency and savings when it comes to the private insurance market.

Claims and the Rising Costs of Healthcare + Treatment

The most obvious answer to why health insurance is so expensive is because healthcare is so expensive.

Of course, new and advanced treatments and technologies can be expensive,7 but even the cost of basic preventive care — screenings, testing and your regular checkup — has increased. For instance, the cost of a pneumococcal vaccine has risen by more than 50% between 2010 and 2017.8

And all that preventative care, as well as the essential health benefits mandated by ACA-compliant plans, is now shared by all healthcare consumers.

Rise of Chronic Illness and Obesity

The increase in healthcare costs can also be attributed in part to lifestyle changes. Chronic disease rates have been on the rise — and they aren’t expected to slow down anytime soon. Do you know anyone with diabetes or heart disease?

Most of us have a friend or family member that has been treated for one of these conditions.

These two illnesses alone are currently responsible for 85% of healthcare costs. Almost half of all Americans have at least one of them.9

The annual costs associated with diabetes care in the U.S., for example, have risen from $174 billion in 2007 to $327 billion in 2017.10

Today, people with chronic conditions account for:

  • 81% of hospital admissions
  • 91% of prescriptions filled
  • 76% of all physician visits11

The cost associated with treating chronic and obesity-related diseases is expected to continue to grow12 and is shared by all healthcare consumers — not just those affected.

Recent Rollbacks + Changes to the ACA

Both official changes to the Affordable Care Act and informal and proposed changes in the last two years have destabilized the insurance industry, which may ultimately contribute to increased costs for consumers.13

Official changes include the:

One of the concerns with the Affordable Care Act from day one was that only sick people would purchase coverage, significantly increasing insurance premiums.

However, the individual mandate and its associated penalty encouraged more people, even those that were healthy, to enroll.

At the same time, curbing the availability of non-major medical plans like short-term health insurance and Association health plans helped drive a higher number of younger and healthier people to ACA plans, which helped control healthcare costs.

Without those rules in place, the costs of claims rises and is passed on to consumers.

If enough of these seemingly small rollbacks and changes to the ACA occur, it could send the program into what’s been dubbed a “death spiral.”14 That could ultimately lead to the end of the program as it becomes too expensive for both insurers and consumers to participate.

Some other proposed and informal changes that have also contributed to undermining the ACA and destabilizing the marketplace, include:

  • Reducing the amount of time you have to enroll in a plan – the open enrollment period was cut in half during the Trump Administration’s first year, from 12 weeks down to just 6 weeks15
  • Reducing the amount of money spent on promoting the ACA and healthcare.gov by 90%, from $100 million during the Obama Administration’s last year to just $10 million in the Trump Administration’s first year16
  • The proposed repeal of pre-existing conditions coverage
  • Removing guidance for consumers about the ACA from hhs.gov17

We simply don’t know yet what the financial impact of these maneuvers will be to consumers. However, even after two years of changes, the ACA remains in-tact, with a larger percentage of insured Americans in 2018 than there were in 2013.18

Lack of Competition with Fewer Carriers and Plan Options

Having more choices generally means you have more control over what you pay for your healthcare coverage. Insurance company failures, mergers and exits from the ACA market mean that many parts of the country, particularly rural areas, have only one option for coverage.

In fact, studies have shown that fewer insurers can lead to lower payments for doctors and higher premiums for patients.19

By State – In 2014, the first year the ACA’s individual mandate was in effect, there were an average of 5 insurers participating in each state’s ACA marketplace, ranging from one company in New Hampshire and West Virginia to 16 companies in New York.

By 2018, the average number of companies per state was 3.5. Eight states (Alaska, Delaware, Iowa, Mississippi, Nebraska, Oklahoma, South Carolina and Wyoming) had only one insurer.

For 2019 open enrollment, a number of insurers entered the market or expanded their service; however, it only brought the average number of carriers to 4 per state, with five states (Alaska, Delaware, Mississippi, Nebraska and Wyoming) with just one insurer.

Rural vs. Urban – Rural areas tend to have fewer insurers, with just 1.8 average insurers in non-metro counties and 2.3 insurers in metro counties in 2019.20

Some places that saw insurers enter the market experienced lower premiums. For example, in the most competitive market in Memphis, the cheapest mid-level plan for 2019 health coverage costs $498 a month for a 40-year-old — a 17% decrease from last year.21

Skyrocketing Costs of Prescription Drugs

A trip to the pharmacy can give you a serious case of sticker shock. The rise of drug prices is outpacing all other areas of healthcare spending.22

Americans spent $535 billion on prescription drugs 2018, an increase of 50% since 2010, according to estimates from The PEW Charitable Trusts.23

Total Prescription Drug Expenditures (Billions of Dollars)24

Chart showing dramatic increase in prescription drugs from 1978 to 2026

Image credit: Peter G. Petersen Foundation

If that wasn’t challenging enough for insurers and consumers, at the beginning of 2019 drug companies announced price hikes on more than 1,000 medications.25 Prescription medications now make up an estimated 17% of overall healthcare expenses.

Why are prescription drugs so expensive? The situation is due in part to government regulations, according to a study by the Harvard Medical School and the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health in Boston.26

These regulations allow drug manufacturers to avoid competing market forces, the researchers believe. Drug makers can charge high prices for drugs thanks largely to “market exclusivity” regulations intended to allow them to recoup initial research and development costs.

For example, a new drug can have a period of market exclusivity that lasts from five to 12 years. During that period, no low-cost generic version of that drug can be sold. The exclusivity period can be extended by “evergreening,” when drug companies renew their market exclusivity by patenting a new slightly different version of the same drug.

Drug companies can do this largely unopposed because the nation’s largest health insurers, Medicare and Medicaid — which cover one in three Americans, are prohibited to negotiate prices by federal law.

While the ACA contained many new regulations for insurers, it left the pharmaceutical industry largely unregulated, which means fewer drug cost protections for consumers.

Trying to Lower Your Monthly Premium?

Here are some things to keep in mind if you’re trying to lower your monthly premium.

See if you qualify for a federal subsidy

If you’re enrolled in an ACA-qualifying major medical plan, you may qualify for a subsidy for your monthly health insurance premiums.

Find Out if You Could Get a Federal Subsidy

But you can only take advantage of these subsidies during the annual open enrollment period or if you qualify for a special enrollment period.

Do you qualify for a special enrollment period?

Find Out if You Qualify

Consider non-ACA health insurance options

While major medical coverage is a good option for most people, there are lower-premium non-major medical health insurance options available, including short term insurance.

These plans are especially helpful when you’re uninsured and unable to obtain major medical coverage until an open enrollment or special enrollment period, but you can also consider them as lower-premium offerings if you want a less comprehensive plan.

Remember, these are not major medical policies. The lower-cost premium will mean fewer benefits and less coverage than a major medical plan and not all insurance is guaranteed issue, meaning you can be denied coverage.

Get an Instant STM Quote

Increase your deductible amount

You can save on premiums by increasing your deductible. The more you pay out of pocket — whether you have a group or individual health plan — the less you will have to pay in premiums.

Keep health insurance in mind when you’re moving

It’s a smart idea to keep health insurance costs in mind when you’re making life change decisions. When considering a new job or moving to a different part of the country, for instance, remember that where you live can make a difference in what you pay for health insurance.

Healthcare costs less in some parts of the country and whether you’re in a rural vs urban setting can also make a difference. Insurance companies in healthcare markets with more consumers and providers can negotiate service prices of up to 19% lower, according to a 2017 study.27

Summary + Next Steps

The factors that make health insurance so expensive are largely out of our control, but choosing the right coverage can help make sure the money you do spend gets you the best health insurance to meet your needs.

Learn more about major medical insurance and decide if it’s right for you.

You can also:

Want personalized help understanding your options? Call 888-855-6837 to speak with a licensed insurance agent.

Need Supplemental or Short Term Insurance?

Apply in 3 Easy Steps

  • Get a quote within seconds
  • Compare multiple plans
  • Finish application online

Originally Published On June 4th, 2019
Independence American Insurance Company and/or Madison National Life Insurance Company, Inc. may underwrite the products referenced on this website. Legal Disclaimers.

Footnotes